Thucydides criticism of democratic knowledge

Princeton/Stanford Working Papers in Classics

VVv aj30vAia Kat "necessity" 1. The arrival of the Sophist philosophers in Athens occurred during his middle life, and he seems to have taken full advantage of the society of Zeno and particularly Anaxagorasfrom whom he is said to have learned impassivity in the face of trouble and insult and skepticism about alleged divine phenomena.

Athens became rich and powerful. The classic example is the statement "I pronounce you man and wife. One hundred years later, an orator argued for firm distinctions of status on the ground that the law provided even the poorest Athenian girl with a dowry in the form of her citizenship.

Conventional moral considerations play no role in his analysis of political events while geographic and ethnographic aspects are omitted or, at best, of secondary importance. What the demos collectively opined was given, through the act of voting, the status of fact.

Since the appearance of her study, other scholars further examined Thucydides's treatment of realpolitik.

It is through the witness of great proofs see before you. In essence, he was a well-connected gentleman of considerable resources who, after involuntarily retiring from the political and military spheres, decided to fund his own historical investigations.

Josiah Ober, "Solon and the Horoi. The law also may have passed because of a general wish to restrict access to the benefits of office and public distributions, but there was never any disposition on the part of Athenians to restrict economic opportunities for foreigners—who served in the fleet, worked on public buildings, and had freedom of trade and investment, with the crucial, but normal, exception of land and houses.

As a result, the classical Greek experience has more to tell us about the origins and definition of democracy, and about the relationship between participatory democracy and formal institutions, rhetoric, civic identity, political values, political criticism, war, economy, culture, and religion.

Pericles thought and acted swiftly. Athenian political practice and policy remained flexible because in frequent meetings of the assembly and the people's courts contrasting views were publicly aired. The first European translation of Thucydides into Latin was made by the humanist Lorenzo Valla between andand the first Greek edition was published by Aldo Manuzio in A celebrated example is Pericles' funeral orationwhich heaps honour on the dead and includes a defence of democracy: He would evacuate the Athenian countryside, bring the population into the Long Walls, decline battle with the Spartan army, and rely on the fleet to assure Athenian food supplies and secure the empire on whose resources the expensive naval policy depended.

Greek historians of the fourth century BC accepted that history was political and that contemporary history was the proper domain of a historian. Euboeacrucial to Athenian control of the sea and food supplies, and Megara soon followed suit.

A similar sentiment is expressed a lives fighting for the common good, the speech emphasizes Athenian free- few lines later: For their self-sacrifice see 2. Kenneth Dover has argued that "an archaic mode of indicating that a man was all that a man should be confined itself to two aspects of his character, his valour on the battlefield and his wisdom in discussion sc.

Leo Strauss (in The City and Man) locates the problem in the nature of Athenian democracy itself, about which, he argued, Thucydides had a deeply ambivalent view: on one hand, Thucydides's own "wisdom was made possible" by the Periclean democracy, which had the effect of liberating individual daring, enterprise, and questioning spirit;.

Athenian Identity and Civic Ideology ~ EDITED BY Alan·L. Boegehold AND democratic knowledge and underlie Athens'civic ideology.

To what extent is Thucydides critical of democracy? Is he less critical of democracy than Plato is?

pattern in the text is significant from the perspective of criticism of de­ mocracy. As Thucydides has explained, most Athenians believe silly.

Whereas there is a danger in assessing Thucydides’ political views through biographies, (Maitland. Marcellinus’ Life of Thucydides: Criticism and Criteria in the Biographical.

The Classical Quarterly, 46, 2, if Thucydides sees faults in democracy, perhaps his favour lies with another form of political government; the problem.


Pericles' Anatomy of Democratic Courage. Ryan Balot. "Thucydides' Criticism of Democratic Knowledge." In Nomodeiktes: History is an advocate of and spokesman for participatory democracy, and develops a notion of courage in light of his democratic ideals, Thucydides.

Thucydides points out the government (TO OlKELV) favors the interests of the majority (E~ 7fAEiova~) that if future generations were to judge by the physical magnificence of the rather than of the few (E~ oAiyov~). Nomodeiktes Thucydides' Criticism of Democratic Knowledge 95 As modern readers now know.

Thucydides' Criticism of Democratic Knowledge 83 institutions was to pronounce statements that were efficacious or "felici- tous" (Austin's preferred term). rather than statements that were in some ontologically pure sense "true. democracy was not ossified. row- ers to row.

Thucydides Thucydides criticism of democratic knowledge
Rated 3/5 based on 55 review
Thucydides' Criticism of Democratic Knowledge | Josiah Ober -